Rafferty v. Xinhua Finance Limited is a significant case in Canadian law concerning reasonable expectations of parties in contract law, particularly regarding the exercise of contractual discretion. The case, heard by the Ontario Court of Appeal in 2013, involved a dispute over deferred compensation owed to Michael Rafferty, a former executive of Xinhua Finance Limited.
Rafferty had been employed by Xinhua under an employment agreement that included a deferred compensation plan. This plan allowed for the payment of compensation in the future, contingent on certain conditions. Crucially, the plan gave Xinhua’s board of directors discretion to determine the amount and timing of these payments. After Rafferty’s employment ended, a dispute arose regarding the payment of his deferred compensation.
Xinhua argued that the board had exercised its discretion and determined that Rafferty was not entitled to the full amount claimed. They asserted that the plan provided them with broad authority to make such decisions and that their decision was reasonable considering the circumstances.
Rafferty, on the other hand, argued that Xinhua had not exercised its discretion in good faith and that their decision was unreasonable. He contended that the board’s decision was motivated by factors unrelated to the purposes of the deferred compensation plan, such as a desire to reduce costs or punish him for leaving the company. He argued that the discretion granted to the board was not unfettered and that it had to be exercised reasonably and in accordance with the principles of good faith.
The Ontario Court of Appeal ultimately ruled in favor of Rafferty. The Court emphasized that even when a contract grants one party discretionary power, that discretion must be exercised reasonably and in good faith. It held that Xinhua’s board had not acted reasonably in exercising its discretion regarding Rafferty’s deferred compensation.
The Court found that the board had considered irrelevant factors when making its decision. It highlighted that the reasons given by Xinhua for reducing the compensation were not consistent with the purpose of the deferred compensation plan, which was to incentivize and retain key employees. The Court concluded that the board had acted in a manner that was inconsistent with the reasonable expectations of the parties at the time the contract was formed.
Rafferty v. Xinhua Finance Limited is important because it clarifies the limitations on contractual discretion in Canadian law. It underscores that even when a contract appears to grant broad discretionary powers, those powers must be exercised reasonably, in good faith, and in a manner consistent with the purpose of the contract. The case serves as a reminder that courts will scrutinize the exercise of contractual discretion to ensure that it is not used to unfairly prejudice the other party or undermine the fundamental principles of contract law. It is a key case cited in discussions about contractual interpretation and the obligation of good faith in contractual performance.
200×200 xinhua finance logo png vector ai from seeklogo.com 
320×414 xinhua finance ipo from www.slideshare.net 
300×197 search xinhua logo png vectors from seeklogo.com 
174×101 xinhua finance logo png from iconape.com 
850×516 obor map xfa xinhua finance agency xinhua from www.researchgate.net 
1024×720 xinhua finance limited sues pan sutong chairman goldin group from www.dimsumdaily.hk 
400×400 jennifer rafferty ff news fintech finance from ffnews.com 
800×443 media outreach forms partnership xinhua finance agency marketing from www.marketing-interactive.com 
1001×1600 rafferty images stock objects vectors shutterstock from www.shutterstock.com 
612×407 li xinhua stock high res pictures images getty images from www.gettyimages.in 
750×1000 rafferty coat arms rafferty family crest william martin from www.redbubble.com 
697×1024 sarah rafferty marc cains limited edition charity bag from www.gettyimages.in 
462×485 americor selects finance executive barry rafferty chief financial from www.prweb.com 
926×485 xinhua finance smart china expo kaizhou forum discusses build from www.prnewswire.com 
824×1390 claire rafferty res stock photography images alamy from www.alamy.com 
880×1390 rafferty law res stock photography images alamy from www.alamy.com 
1080×565 xinhua finance harnessing wisdom jiangbeizui embarking from www.prnewswire.com 
1000×1266 chips rafferty dream permanent australian picture industry from hunterlivinghistories.com 
1000×524 xinhua silk road northeast asia finance conference opens from www.newswire.ca 
606×163 xinhua finance agency from en.xfafinance.com 
